borned talent VS nurtured talent. who win?

Imagine this two situation :

Student A is a borned percussion talent, and have rhythmic blood, meaning whereever he goes, rhythm is always beating somewhere in his body or mind . He's not forced to learn percussion, it's just the interest. He didn't went to any expensive percussion course, jsut a few private lessons, and school activites. Student A is bad at reading scores. He plays from his heart. The rhythm comes out from his heart naturally.


Student B's parent forced him to go for percussion lessons. He goes for lots of music lessons, and went for expensive percussion classes, and eventually became good at it. He can sightread ( read straight from the scores and play) very very well.

Now both of them went for a percussion competition. The main aim of the competition is to choose the one with the most brilliant flair for percussive music. So, who win?